|
Recent Articles |
Euro gamers get hands on Halo 3
Gamers across Europe got their hands on Halo 3 at midnight on Tuesday, one of the most anticipated and heavily marketed titles in history. In the UK more than 1,000 shops opened at midnight so gamers could...
European web host goes carbon neutral
Europe's second largest web host is to become the first company to power its computer centres entirely from renewable energy. Strato claims that its 30,000 dedicated servers and matrix web hosting platform will be 100 ....
Europe’s new ‘monopoly’ tariff on Microsoft...
The European Commission has just levied a new $689,900,000 “fine” (read: tariff) on American software company Microsoft under the pretense of anti-trust which conveniently bypasses WTO agreements. The Brussels...
Europe indifferent on mobile TV
Europeans' interest in watching mobile television is as tiny as mobile-phone screens, a new study showed on Monday, even though the industry has been buzzing about offering TV on handsets for years. Mobile...
Europe indifferent on mobile TV
Europeans' interest in watching mobile television is as tiny as mobile-phone screens, a new study showed on Monday, even though the industry has been buzzing about offering TV on handsets for years. Mobile...
|
|
|
09.26.07
Won't We Ever Learn?
 By
Shel Holtz
Microsoft and global PR agency Burson-Marsteller are in hot water over a tactic that flies in the face of what we know about the nature of business and transparency in the era of social computing.
There have been enough instances of false-front organizations, funded by a client and operated by a PR agency, being outed by determined individuals to make you wonder: What in the world was Burson thinking?
The tale-as recounted in this Guardian story-begins with an email from Burson director Jonathan Dinkeldein promoting the Initiative for Competitive Online Marketplaces. The email, delivered to boad membes of several several top UK businesses. The message-characterized by some recipients as an inappropriate cold call-solicited membership in the organization that was opposing Google's acquisition of DoubleClick, the online marketing organization Google acquired in an auction. The email noted that the Initiative for Competitive Online Marketplaces would soon issue messages addressing Google, Internet privacy, and competition.
Microsoft lost out to Google in the bidding and, as it turns out, Microsoft is represented by Burson in such matters. To make things worse, a Microsoft spokesperson would only admit that the software giant and Burson have a relationship but denied that Burson was lobbying on Microsoft's behalf. Dinkeldein, in the meantime, did admitted that Burson was working with Microsoft on the DoubleClick matter and that Microsoft had formed the organization. Geez, can't a PR agency and a client even get their stories straight?
There is nothing inherently wrong with Microsoft forming the organization-such organizations can actually have a legitimate cause and serve a worthwhile purpose. Nor is there anything wrong with a PR agency working with the company to promote the organization. What is wrong-terribly, unethically wrong-is failing to disclose those relationships. And there have been enough instances in recent years to make you wonder what it will take for this simple fact to permeate the practices of the public relations profession.
The world is transparent, and many eyes are focused on the lens peering into the business world. Deceit will be exposed. There is no benefit in trying to get away with something like this, which only hurts the public relations profession, including those who would never engage in such practices. A comment by David Binkowski to the TechDirt report on the kerfuffle articulates the same concern:
I know most people hate PR firms but there are people on the inside showing the light-these types of tactics are unethical and need to be exposed. The consumer revolution will take full hold when we start boycotting the brands of the firms representing this kind of dishonesty.
The TechDirt post, by the way, carries this subhead: from the lobbyists-and-shills-and-pr,-oh-my! dept
Can't you just feel that brush spreading its paint all over you?
Hat tip to Jim Horton.
Comments
About the Author:
Shel Holtz is principal of Holtz Communication + Technology which focuses on helping organizations apply online communication capabilities to their strategic organizational communications.
As a professional communicator, Shel also writes the blog a shel of my former self.
|
